Skip to main content

Bad Sales Manager Part 1 (Another Dumb Story)

I haven't posted a good "dumb story" in a while, which is unusual since I have so many of them to share. To be honest, I nearly forgot about this incident until the person involved came up in conversation a few weeks back when I was having lunch with a former colleague. Here's what happened.

Several years ago I was working with a company (I will call them Company A) which had a very limited menu of insurance products to offer. The guy who recruited me, Fred*, was a tobacco chewing good old boy who looked like he couldn't get home fast enough to watch reruns of "Hee Haw". He was a member of the management team and, after meeting the rest of them, I realized this was a great example of "birds of a feather". These guys were all used to door-to-door old school selling in low income areas and expected the rest of us to do the same.

Needless to say, I wasn't about to start beating on doors in trailer parks for business. Not that there's anything wrong with these people, but when it comes to selling insurance I want my business to stay on the books, and historically this was not the case. 

Instead I did business the way I was used to doing it. I called on business owners and went to networking events to find prospects and referrals. Keeping my head down I put up some decent numbers. 

One day Fred insisted on doing one of his obligatory "ride alongs" where he was supposed to go with me on appointments and watch me in action. I explained my sales strategy as he sat in the passenger seat next to me, spitting tobacco juice out of the window when the opportunity arose. I even took him with me to a ribbon cutting for a new business to do some networking. He looked like a fish out of water when he was in the midst of actual business professionals. 

Another thing to keep in mind was that this company, like many life insurance companies, had a revolving door when it came to agents. Every week we had a few more new faces while others mysteriously disappeared. Like I have mentioned in the past, insurance agents rarely get fired because they quit way before that happens because they aren't making money. 

It was a surprise to all of us when Fred announced at one of our mandatory Friday morning meetings that he was leaving the company and going to work for one of our competitors. The other company (I will call them Company B) was not much better than the one I was currently with, but they did have a few more products. Apparently he was going to be making a bit more money and he was ready to poach as many of us as possible.  

Fred immediately took a handful of agents with him to his new company. To be honest, I don't think anyone really noticed. I tried to stay out of the office as much as possible by working and producing just enough to keep from having to attend "call parties", where the managers would provide pizza in exchange for us working the phones during the evening. 

About this time I had a call from a very large insurance company who wanted me to come work with them. There was a problem though. Their onboarding process took several months instead of days like most insurance carriers. This new company (we will call them Company C) paid great commissions, had higher standards and overall was more professional. I wouldn't have to worry about tobacco juice splattered on the side of my car if a manager rode with me.

And that was when I had to make a decision. 

Stay tuned for the next post when I describe how Fred and I crossed paths again. In the meantime, stay healthy!

*I've changed the names to protect me.  

Chris Castanes is a professional speaker who helps sales people succeed through workshops and humorous presentations. He's also the author of "You're Going To Be Great At This!", a humorous look at sales. For booking information, click here. He's also the president of Surf Financial Brokers selling life and disability insurance in several states.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Introducing the "You're Going To Be Great At This!" Podcast

I was pretty surprised when I saw that my last blog post was several months ago. Time really does fly when you're having fun, or in my case, just having a busy workload. In the last few months I've been on the road for an approximate total of 9 weeks. Needless to say I get less than motivated to work in a hotel room after selling insurance for 8 hours, so blogging isn't on my "to do" list. While driving in my car during these trips I try to make my time productive my listening to podcasts on business and marketing. I'm not sure if someone was trying to tell me something but over the course of a week or so, I heard 4 episodes on how starting a podcast can help boost your business. After mulling this over and considering my options, I decided to take the plunge and start one myself. I've had a YouTube channel for a while which is fine, but I wanted to do something a little different. So I decided to start the "You're Going To Be Great At This!"...

Changing My Scheduling Calendar For 2025

This blog usually has actionable sales tips and advice to help you succeed in your business. This time, I wanted to take a look at another part of your business, which is scheduling appointments or sales calls or whatever you need to schedule.  Having a scheduling calendar that your prospects can make your job so much easier. Instead of calling back and forth to pin a time to meet down, you can let your prospect/client pick their own time. According to FinancesOnline.com, online scheduling can lead to 26% more customers, so sharing your calendar is a real no-brainer. I have a Google calendar that I use to book appointments, but I have also been using Calendly and sharing it on my website and social media. The two calendars are supposed to sync up to avoid double bookings, but recently I discovered an issue.  I had blocked out a couple of days on my Google calendar for a business conference, but Calendly was still showing those days as available. After trying to find a way to f...

Your Sales Call Autopsy

A friend of mine recently did some contract work for a company. The project took several weeks and the work was much more detailed than my friend anticipated. Not only was the work itself difficult, but so were the other people who he had to deal with while completing the designs and other specifications.  When he was done he did something very important. He waited a few days and then took an objective look at the entire process, where he discovered what worked well, what didn't work well and the lessons he learned in the process. He even posted all of this information in a "bullet point" style on social media. With that information, his future projects will be somewhat easier if he runs into the same issues. Many people in sales and marketing fail to do this. If something works well, they just move on to the next deal. But if they hit a snag and fail to get the sale, they complain about something, usually the client or the working conditions, without having an honest ass...